How it’s framed matters

How it’s framed matters

The Covid-19 pandemic highlighted the divide between those eager for a vaccine and those who, for various reasons, avoided them regardless of public health messaging. How can we best communicate with a vaccine-hesitant person about potential benefits?

There’s no easy answer, but new research involving Yang (Jenny) Guo, assistant professor of marketing at Binghamton University, New York, found that a one-size-fits-all approach to communicating isn’t effective. Message framing plays a crucial role dependent on mindset, requiring different types of communication for different people. 

The paper, “Loss Framing Increases Entity Theorists’ Vaccine Uptake”, published in the International Journal of Research in Marketing, determined that loss-based messaging is the most constructive method to communicate with vaccine-hesitant people to inform them about the scope of their decision. Guo says those with a fixed mindset (here, those most likely to refuse vaccines) respond better to messaging framed around negative aspects of not getting vaccinated, rather than around positive outcomes of vaccination. 

“It’s an interesting contrast to what you might see in a bulk of the message framing for vaccines that promotes a ‘new normal’ and how taking them helps people gain something,” she adds.

By contrast, message framing was found to not impact people with a “growth mindset” (a belief that characteristics can be changed through individual efforts). They believe efforts lead to positive changes, so may be motivated to make such efforts regardless of message framing.

The research suggests that in the event of another pandemic, loss framing would be a better strategy to promote a vaccine. Guo stresses that gain-framing will not persuade the people health officials really need to reach: the extremely vaccine-hesitant. 

Published by

SHEQ Management

SHEQ MANAGEMENT is the definitive source for reliable, accurate and pertinent information to guarantee environmental health and safety in the workplace.
Prev From old tyres to new car parts
Next Expanding roots for a brighter future

Leave a comment