Love as a KPI
Love as a KPI
In a world obsessed with metrics, can we truly measure what matters most? Our columnist challenges our reliance on numbers, using an unexpected wedding to demonstrate the limitations of quantifying human experiences.
My mother got married on 7 September. What does this have to do with safety? Not much, you might think, but I’ll reveal its importance via a risk assessment (using the template provided below).
TASK: Wedding
LOCATION: Sopot, Poland
EQUIPMENT DESCRIPTION: Two people in their 70s
- The newlyweds are almost in their 70s; “giving someone your heart” at that age can be a rather daunting experience. The fear of being hurt is often difficult to explain, but you could say that the likelihood of having your heart broken in your 70s would certainly have a “catastrophic” impact and cause “permanent impairment”. For these reasons, the risk rating would be 25.
- With a likelihood of “very unlikely” for a Polish couple, they signed a prenuptial agreement, so some might say that the consequences for “minimal or no injuries” are low, resulting in a risk rating of 1.
- Both individuals are physically healthy, take care of their bodies, and consume numerous supplements. However, given their age, a consequence of “minor injuries and first aid cases” meets a “possible” likelihood, which leaves them with a moderate risk rating of 6.
- My mother’s side of the family has a history of not-very-serious heart conditions; therefore, the “likely” likelihood of consequentially “moderate injuries and medical treatment” is quite high, describing the risk rating as 12.
- The newlyweds have four daughters, and 75% of those children thought the likelihood of the wedding even happening was “unlikely”. However, if anyone dared to say anything negative about the event, the consequences of “serious injuries and even hospitalisation” could be described as moderate, scoring 8 on the risk rating.
- Additional note: The happiness of the couple getting married was so high that no measurement could describe how fabulous the day was.
This risk assessment demonstrates that there are many things we should never attempt to measure; that no matter how many matrices and charts we fill out, most of them will only show a fraction of the situation and therefore a fraction of the risk.
In the risk and safety field, we should not fixate on measurements as much as we do. Yes, numbers speak louder than words, but I would encourage you to look beyond the numbers. There is nothing wrong with having a clear, numeric indication regarding many aspects of our personal or professional lives. It is incorrect, however, to assume that everything that can be measured is important.
True or False: “You can’t manage what you can’t measure”
This statement is frequently cited, especially in risk and safety, but also in the business management world. Growthink.com describes this quote as emphasising “the importance of quantifiable metrics in managing and improving processes or any organisational function. Measuring outcomes is key to evaluating strategies and actions effectively”.
Sources variously attribute the quote to either Peter Drucker – who wrote 39 books about business management and is widely regarded as the greatest management thinker of all time – or W. Edwards Deming, the statistician and quality-control expert credited with having launched the Total Quality Management (TQM) movement.
However, customer experience expert Don Peppers – a keynote speaker, business author, and founder of Peppers & Rogers Group – argues that both men were far too intelligent and astute to ever have articulated anything so simplistic and misleading.
One of the “seven deadly diseases” of management that Deming himself warned about was the dangerously misguided practice of running a business solely on visible figures. He emphasised that “nothing becomes more important just because you can measure it. It becomes more measurable, that’s all”.
This insight underscores the pressing need for a deeper understanding of qualitative factors in business decision-making, which extends beyond mere numbers and quantitative data, inviting a more holistic approach to evaluate truly critical aspects of performance and innovation.

Managing is much more than just measuring
Every single day, we are submerged in data, either in the professional sphere – for example by Key Performance Indicators (KPIs), Total Recordable Cases Rates (TRCR), and Lost Time Injuries (LTIs) – or in our private lives.
Online algorithms track our exact online behaviours, translating them into personalised ads. Anyone who has searched for something online will have experienced this – soon enough, an ad promoting that exact thing will pop up in the corner of the screen. This is a simple example of how measurements of our online activity are constantly being managed.
In an everyday setting, however, our brains perceive data differently compared to a computer program. It is essential to recognise not only what we can do with data, but also the limits of what it can tell us. Today’s data-driven world contains too many numbers and algorithms – to the point where they can corrupt our thinking.
What is actually being measured?
A couple of articles ago, I mentioned that I worked for a major Middle Eastern airline. I still remember how in one quarterly meeting with my manager, she mentioned that I might be due for a promotion.
Of course, upon hearing this I was overjoyed, until I heard what needed to be done to receive the upgrade. I needed to pass the interview, have perfect attendance, write a journal for almost eight months about many industry-specific questions (answers to which I would have to find out on my assigned flights), and, most importantly, “let the company get to know me”.
In all honesty, I had no idea what she meant. I knew that I was just a number among 47,000 other employees, but I thought that a company which had hired me six years earlier, was responsible for all my legal and visa-related documents, and held my medical history at the company clinic, knew me “well enough”. I was wrong …
Seeing the confusion on my face, the manager explained that I should write reports from every single flight. “The more, the better,” she insisted. After that meeting, a couple of my friends were gracious enough to explain what my manager meant. All I had to do was write whatever was happening on the flight. My friend informed me that back in the day, she would write two to four reports per flight, but as soon as she started writing more, she was “seen”, so now she was writing 300 reports per flight (to the point that the report-writing homework usually took longer than the actual flight). Of course, she got her promotion.
When I naively asked, “But what happens when there is nothing to write about?” my friend told me that 85% of what she wrote was not true, but the number of submitted reports made her “visible”. Three other friends admitted to doing the same thing, and many others I met later also confessed to their 85% of lies. Yes, numbers speak louder than words and they do not lie, but the people who generate them might.
At times things are no different in risk and safety, or leadership in general. Leaders set various indicators and link them to bonus-related targets. However, this can come with a risk and a trade-off. If the targets are not reachable, people may start to falsify their numbers.
For example, if a company sets the requirement of conducting a large number of management audits, but the managers do not have the resources or time to complete them, these could become “desktop audits”, fabricated by managers while sitting at their desks, without even going out onto the shop floor where the audits should be conducted. Because they do not want to lose their bonus or be seen in an unfavourable light, the temptation is to falsify the records and the numbers that are being measured.
The same applies to companies measuring injury rates and driving for sites to attain the unachievable goal of Zero Harm. When someone inevitably gets injured, they would rather sweep it under the carpet than report it and reflect an unsatisfactory number (and, even worse, lose their bonus).
Leaders often develop a false sense of security when seeing that the numbers set for various KPIs are being achieved or even overachieved. The graphs and numbers in presentations at management meetings reflect good performance; but even though the numbers are being achieved and bonuses paid out, the quality of the efforts is low and adds little value.
Measuring love …
This illustrates one of the most central and pressing problems afflicting business managers in today’s rapidly evolving and complex landscape – particularly in an era increasingly dominated by the influence of Big Data and the emergence of highly sophisticated, algorithmic decision-making processes. Quantifying various aspects of business operations and overall performance has increasingly become an easy and convenient way for many managers to escape accountability and the need to adequately use ordinary human judgement or a well-considered, intelligent perspective. As Pepper said, “Measuring something doesn’t make it manageable. It just makes it measurable.”
But what about things that leaders cannot measure? Things like care, support, guidance, respect, and engagement with team members can never be measured, but are just as important in leading people and managing a company. Moreover, they reflect good leadership qualities and contribute to a healthy company culture.
We must always remember that any measurement is only as strong as its weakest algorithm or assessment, and some things will always be impossible to measure … like love, even at the age of 70.
Published by
Aneta Darlington
sheqmag_sa
